Senator Elton and Isabel
off the record
a VIP policy letter
from
Senator Kim Elton
Room 115, State Capitol, Juneau, AK 99801 * 465-4947 Phone * 465-2108 FAX

Edition # 188                   Please feel free to forward                 November 26, 2004

 

Capitol Undercurrents

     

Is It Really News or is It MemorXXXX'd?

 
How 'bout that--Rep. Beth (Kerttula) has now spent more time in the legislative majority than I have. During the brief House coup, she spent about 30 hours as a member of the legislative majority.
 
Offered without comment--A Los Angeles Times correction: "The Inside Politics column in the Nov. 8 California sectioncontained an item about an election night celebration that said several local prosecutors appeared to have made frequent trips to the open bar. It was a cash bar."
 
Good little doggy--People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals just launched a fish "empathy" campaign to encourage consumers not to eat fish. The campaign encourages people to think of fish like they think of their pets--as sentient beings and not food. The Seattle P-I quoted one Seattle commercial fisherman who fishes for salmon on a 40-foot fishing vessel with his brother and their West Highland Terrier named Dolly as saying they wouldn't eat Dolly "unless we run out of fish".
 
Spelcheck--Governing Magazine reports that Livermore, California spent $40,000 on a mural near the entrance of their new public library that portrayed the tree of knowledge with small portraits of great artists, writers, scientists and others. Of the 175 words on the mural, 11 were misspelled--including scientist 'Einstein' (Eistein), playwright 'Shakespeare' (Shakespere), and painter 'Gauguin' (Gaugan). The artiste was asked to return and fix the misspellings but responded with a no dice. "People that really love art, they wouldn't even have noticed it if [city officials] hadn't pointed it out." What, she didn't think library patrons would notice?
 
Pay as you don't go--The New York Times reported that the five wealthiest states were all blue (meaning they voted for Kerry) and that they paid nearly $68 billion more in taxes than they got back in federal services while the five poorest states were all red and received $33 billion more in services than they paid in taxes. The newspaper also reported that the Bible Belt states were red and have divorce rates around 50 percent higher than the national average while blue state Massachusetts has the lowest divorce rate.
 

Phone: (907) 465-4947
Fax: (907) 465-2108
Mail: Sen. Elton, State Capitol
Juneau, AK 99801
Email:
Senator.Kim.Elton
Jesse.Kiehl
Paula.Cadiente
Web:
http://elton.akdemocrats.org
     The governor is aggressively sprinkling pixie dust all over his record as the 10th chief executive of our grand state.
    A couple of months ago he caused to be written and distributed a progress report as seen through his eyes entitled A Return to Common Sense. A week or so ago the governor inserted a 12-page tabloid in major-city newspapers with a masthead that trumpeted Breaking New Trails.
     Now his press guru says the governor wants to star in a half-hour weekly show with a faux news anchor supplied by the governor's publicity office. The show would give the governor a unique-in-the-annals-of-Alaska opportunity to spin his leadership and would be underwritten by corporate or individual sponsors that pick up the cost of airtime (though not the cost of production or state staff diverted to the effort).
     The black ops side of this vigorous PR initiative is a behind the scenes press intimidation effort. The governor's chief of staff has been quietly involved in at least two attempts in recent weeks to negatively affect the employment of Alaska journalists who seem to be allergic to political pixie dust designed to make the governor soar. Both journalists, so far, have survived the fits of pique-ishness from the third floor.
     To be fair, part of what the governor does is boilerplate for politicians, including me. I do an end of session newsletter, sometimes in tabloid newspaper style, that recounts what did and didn't happen and not coincidentally mentions my successes and what remains to be accomplished. Production and distribution costs for this annual newsletter come from my office account and indirectly from me (office accounts are handled in two ways: legislators get a check at the beginning of the year to spend however they want or, for those of us who opt for an itemized account, whatever is left at the end of the year is remitted to us in the form of a check). 
     I also do this electronic newsletter twice a month during the interim and once a week during the session. Because I write it and it's distributed via email there are no production or distribution costs. This forum is less newsy and more opinion-oriented. My main goal here is to let constituents know what and how I'm thinking and to spark a dialogue on public policy issues.
     Most other legislators do the session newsletter and many do special reports throughout the year. None of the legislators' efforts, though, are as aggressively positive or as sophisticated as the governor's reports and newsletters. That could be because either we are more even handed or because we don't have 10 employees doing communication/press/constituent relations work that is supplemented with help from press liaison folks in 14 state agencies.
     Most legislators, too, are smart enough to avoid recommending to news executives who they should hire or fire. We understand the culture of journalism and know that news folks are unlikely to make employment decisions based on what a politician wants. In fact, if a politician wants a journalist fired it generally tends to make them bulletproof in the newsroom.
     And, while some legislators may drool over the idea of a weekly TV program paid for by special interests to spin the issues from their perspective, most would avoid that opportunity because it creates at least an appearance of a conflict. Legislators who didn't avoid the opportunity would run smack up against legislative ethics statutes that prohibit, with a few exceptions not applicable here, a legislator or legislative employee from soliciting, accepting or receiving a gift or gifts worth $250 or more. That law precludes, even if I were so inclined, my solicitation for ads to defray the expense of my end of session newsletter or for pop-up ads in this electronic newsletter.
     The executive branch ethics law isn't quite so definitive. That law provides a public officer can't take a gift if it could be reasonably inferred the gift is intended to influence the performance of an official. Reasonably inferred is tricky. While I may believe that a half-hour fake news program paid for by a generous benefactor who wants to give the guv TV face time so he can spin policies as aggressively as a silk worm on caffeine is a gift that keeps on giving for both the governor and the corporate sponsor, others may disagree.
     Before the governor goes too far down the TV program road, paved by the sponsorship of special interests, he may want to check on the legal propriety with his Attorney General--or not. Maybe not.  The governor probably should have the idea vetted by someone other than the AG who is now being investigated by an independent prosecutor because of his cozy financial relationship with a coal technology firm that became part of a trade agreement he helped negotiate with Taiwan. (Now wouldn't that be interesting if that coal firm wanted to be a sponsor of the guv's TV program?)
     The governor's new and aggressive "is it real or is it Memorex (not real)" PR campaign reminds us we need to be good message consumers. We need to consider the information source because what's written or said reflects the filters it passes through.
     So, when we read the governor's tabloid insert (with a production cost of more than $24,000 not counting state staff time to write and edit), we have to remember this won't be an information source designed to tell us whether the cut of the longevity bonus caused some Alaska seniors to move south and spend their retirement paycheck or investment earnings elsewhere. It won't be the place you go to find out how many families were bumped out of Denali Kid Care or the scoop behind the ethics scandal that forced GOP chair Randy Ruedrich from his $100,000 plus state job.
     And we can't expect the governor's progress report, his list of accomplishments, to tout his effort to allow pollutant mixing zones in salmon spawning areas or tell us how many ferry workers quit instead of following the headquarters to Ketchikan.
     And I doubt, too, that his faux news program, bought and paid for by special interest sponsors, will discuss the disappearance of the Alyeska Central School, the cuts to community schools, or special agreements between resource agencies so all speak with one voice before public hearings on important resource management issues. It is even more unlikely, if a major oil company becomes a sponsor, that the any of the governor's bought and paid for TV programs will discuss a fiscal plan that may include revisiting an oil tax structure that may have worked in the 1980s but may not work in this new century.
 

If you would like to receive this newsletter or if you want to be removed from the mailing list, please contact Paula Cadiente, staff, at paula.cadiente@legis.state.ak.us and have her add or remove your name.

 
View all the back copies of Off the Record at http://elton.akdemocrats.org